When Apple unveiled macOS Tahoe 26, the redesigned Finder icon sparked controversy by moving the iconic blue color to the right side, which was a significant break from nearly three decades of design tradition. Fortunately, the latest beta version of the software has addressed this change, restoring the coloring while preserving the new aesthetic. Apple is often praised for its meticulous attention to detail in design, but occasionally, the desire to innovate leads to choices that do not resonate well with its user base.
Notably, Stephen Hackett, a writer at *512 Pixels* and an Apple historian, pointed out the inconsistency in the new Finder icon’s color scheme. Historically, the darker color has always been positioned on the left side of the icon, making the recent alteration feel abrupt. Thanks to feedback from influential voices like Hackett, the second developer beta introduced an updated icon that adheres more closely to tradition.
During WWDC, Apple SVP Craig Federighi acknowledged Hackett’s concerns, suggesting that Apple values feedback from its community of enthusiasts. This responsiveness highlights the importance of constructive criticism, especially when the company diverges from its historical design principles. The Finder icon’s roots trace back to the System 7.5.3 boot screen, and it has consistently featured a darker color on the left throughout its evolution.
The recent design changes raised questions about whether they were truly necessary or simply a change for change’s sake. The new beta 2 icon reflects a more balanced approach, with the blue color dominating the logo and a transparent white accent, while still respecting the longstanding tradition. In dark mode, the icon again shifts, but the darker gray and black remain on the left, maintaining a connection to its past.
Some have dubbed the new look a “half mask,” referencing theatrical aesthetics, but at least the redesign honors the legacy of the Finder as it adapts to a more modern, glassy style.
Leave a Reply